Sweater Weather | Cutest Finds Under $50!

Happy Friday, friends, and cheers to the weekend!! Can y’all believe Christmas is next weekend already?! My kids finish with school this afternoon, and then it’s full-steam ahead on the holiday cheer for us. It’s also time to get serious about finalizing my gifting… I still have a handful to finish, what about you?!

Texas finally got the Winter memo again, which makes me extra excited for today’s post! I found some of the cutest sweaters for the season, and whether you’re a Neutral Nancy or Bright Betty, there’s something for everyone. Some are already favorites, and some are new finds… and they’re all under $50 and ship free with Prime!


Sizing info: I’m 5’4″ 125-ish pounds, and usually wear an XS/0 and 26 jeans. My fit tips and sizing recommendations are included with each description. 


Sweaters Under $50 //

This sweater has been a favorite for a few years, so I was thrilled to see it in this fun new fair isle pattern! It’s super soft and stretchy, with a slim but not restrictive, fit. The colors of brown, blush, and black are a fun combo for pairing with all sorts of winter bottoms.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small sweater and size 26 jeans.

Crewneck Sweater (Color: Dark Chestnut Brown) | Chew Hem Jeans | Chain Mules | Ivory Headband (code CASSIE15) | Jewelry Set | Leather Woven Tote


Quarter-zip pullovers are my favorite style of sweater for casual days. I love the taller collar and the open neckline is always flattering. This one is soft and oversized, and darling with blue and black denim.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small pullover.

Striped Pullover (Color: Style2-white) | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Similar Loafers | Jewelry Set


I’m always a sucker for stripes, and this cozy crewneck brings the fun with a bold mix of colors, too! It’s equal parts preppy and chic, and pairs with denim and skirts. So cute layered over a collared shirt or under a jacket, too.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size 4 sweater.

Multicolor Striped Sweater (Color: Multi Stripe) | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Block Heel Booties (TTS, Color: Khaki) | Jewelry Set


There was an audible ‘oooooohhhh‘ when I pulled this cardigan on, and I was instantly smitten! It’s crazy soft and so luxe feeling, and the shape is chic and a little sexy. Wear it open over a cami, or buttoned for the perfect top for jeans and trousers.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size XS cardigan, which is a great slim fit, but I’d love a size up for a slouchy look, too.

Cardigan Sweater (Color: Black) | Step Crop Jeans | Buckle Mules (TTS) | Beaded Headband | Jewelry


I wore this sweater in black earlier this week and remembered why I fell in love with it! It’s sporty yet feminine, in a fun hoodie pullover style. It’s also crazy soft and stretchy, and looks cute paired casually with jeans, and dressed up with skirts!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small hoodie.

Hoodie Pullover (Color: Beige) | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Rothy’s Sneakers (SUGARPLUM20 for $20 off your first order over $100) | Jewelry


Bring a little sunshine to dreary winter days with these fun stripes! This tunic-style sweater is crazy soft, with an easy, relaxed fit and longer length.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small sweater.

Striped Tunic (Color: A Colorful) | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Chain Mules | Jewelry | Leather Woven Tote


If I didn’t see the price tag, I’d totally believe this to be a $150 name-brand sweater! It feels dreamy-soft, with a stretchy ribbed texture and medium weight. I love the open collar and quarter zip, and it’s long enough for leggings. It even has a side slit so it doesn’t hug across the bum!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small pullover.

Wide Collar Sweater (Color: C Striped Khaki 2) | Faux Leather Leggings | Block Heel Booties | Jewelry


One of my softest sweaters, I’ve been reaching for this one for years. I love the full sleeves and textured poms for an elevated look at an affordable price point!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size 4-6 sweater.

Pom Pom Sweater | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Block Heel Booties (TTS, Color: Khaki) | Plaid Headband (Color: Brown) | Jewelry


One of my hands-down favorite sweaters… from any retailer, not just Amazon! It’s the perfect weight for being warm, but not bulky and overly hot. I love the shape of the sleeves and the longer length, too.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small tunic.

Oversized Cowlneck Tunic (Color: Rose Red) | Faux Leather Leggings | Block Heel Booties | Jewelry | Beaded Headband


I live in leggings this time of year, so I’m always on the hunt for longer sweaters and tops. This pullover is perfectly slouchy, with the cutest button neck and preppy stripes. It’s also incredibly soft and so comfy.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small sweater.

Oversized Button Tunic (Color: B Stripe Red) | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Block Heel Booties (TTS, Color: Khaki) | Jewelry


So much style packed into one classic sweater! I love the balloon sleeves with the fitted cuff, and the extra padding in the shoulder gives it a great, feminine shape. It’s a soft knit, light enough to tuck in, or wear out. Dress it up with trousers and skirts, or keep it more casual with denim. The red is holiday perfection, too!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size XS sweater and size Small pants.

Bubble Sleeve Sweater (Color: Flame Red) | Wide Leg Crop Pants | Strappy Heels (size up half) | Jewelry Set


Exaggerated shoulders are everywhere right now, and this one has just enough to be stylish and flattering, without being overwhelming. The sleeves are full, but a little on the long side.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small sweater.

Lantern Sleeve Sweater (Color: Solid Pink) | Chew Hem Jeans (Size 26) | Block Heel Booties (TTS, Color: Khaki) | Beaded Headband | Jewelry


Speaking of exaggerated shoulders… how fun is this mock neck pullover?! It has oversized shoulder pads to give it a fuller shape, and a cropped length perfect for high-rise jeans and trousers.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small top and size 26 jeans.

Padded Shoulder Sweater (Color: Apricot) | Wide Leg Jeans (code SUGARPLUM10) | Block Heel Booties (TTS, Color: Khaki) | Bejeweled Headband (code CASSIE15) | Jewelry


Pink and red will forever be my favorite combo, so how could I resist this fun leopard pullover?! It’s soft and fuzzy, with the cutest print. The sleeves have a longer length with bell shape, but I just cuffed them a few times for a better fit.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size XS sweater.

Tiger Striped Sweater (Color: Scarlet/Lavender) | Step Crop Jeans | Block Heel Booties (TTS, Color: Khaki) | Jewelry


And that, friends, is a round-up of some of my favorite sweater finds for the season. As of today, they’re all available for Christmas delivery, too! And of course, they all look darling paired with our Victoria Emerson x Hi Sugarplum Collection!


And if you’re still shopping last minute stocking stuffers, here are some of my favorites….

1. tarte maracuja juicy glow (code CASSIE15) // 2. Nail Wraps
3. To-Do List Pad // 4. Gratitude Journal
5. Drybar Shower Cap // 6. Mini Beauty Must-Haves Set
7. Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask // 8. Kiehl’s Lotion Set
9. Keyring Wristlet // 10. Drybar Rollers
11. Headbands // 12. Initial Necklace
13. Diamond Dazzle Stick // 14. Avocado Keeper



1. Tartan Socks // 2. Mini Waffle Maker
3. Mike’s Hot Honey // 4. Acne Patches
5. tarte concealer and glow duo (code CASSIE15) // 6. Athena Club Razor
7. Face Blotting Paper // 8. Card Game
9. essence Lash Primer (Mascara HERE) // 10. Fine Tip Marker Pens


Did you find some great gifts on Amazon this year? Thanks to Prime shipping, most of it is still projected to arrive before Christmas. Find all my Amazon Fashion Finds HERE.

And for those asking, the fun artwork behind me is HERE. You can find all my Amazon Fashion Finds HERE. And in case you missed it, all of my gift guides for this season are linked below. Happy weekend, lovebugs!

PS – Find my Sugarplum Amazon Shop HERE, with my top picks in a range of categories. I also have a ‘Sugar Shack’ list in my Amazon Store for all lake house links! And if you’re looking for some of my fave random finds, all my Monday Mail Day discoveries are HERE.



All Things Cozy
The Can’t Miss Gift!
Sugarplum Favorite Things
Mama Sugarplum’s Favorite Things
Early Bird’s Gift Guide
For the Fitness Lover
For the Foodie
Faves Under $50
10 Under $10 | Stocking Stuffers
Dressing Room Diaries | Black Friday Edition
Stocking Stuffers
Gifts Under $25
Gifts Under $50
Gifts Under $75
Gifts Under $100
Gifts for Men
Gifts for Teens
Gifts for Littles
Stocking Stuffers Under $10
All Sugarplum Gift Guides HERE

Leave a Comment


  1. Lisa wrote:

    Lots of fun sweaters! I love the 70s vibe of the flare jeans. Happy holidays!

    Posted 12.16.22 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      I’m loving those flares, too! It’s a nice change-up. xo,C

      Posted 12.16.22 Reply
  2. Kelsey wrote:

    Such a great roundup! I have saved a few of these sweaters to my wish list now. Your hair always looks fabulous, and it’s extra cute when straight!

    Posted 12.16.22 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      Thank you, Kelsey!!! xo, C

      Posted 12.16.22 Reply
  3. Arika wrote:

    I caught the hoodie sweater on sale for $16. Whoo ho!

    Posted 12.16.22 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      Oh wowza what a steal!!!! xo, C

      Posted 12.16.22 Reply
  4. Lynn wrote:

    Okay, these sweaters are ALL SO CUTE! It’s hard to pick a favorite but I’m partial to the pastel striped tunic-length one. I also have to say seeing your hair straight?? It looks so good styled that way!

    Posted 12.16.22 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      Thank you so much, Lynn! And yes I’m pretty partial to that pastel stripe as well! xo,C

      Posted 12.16.22 Reply
  5. Katie wrote:

    I love the colors in the pastel tunic but it seems the link goes to a different style sweater? When you have a moment (HA!) can you check? It would be a nice change of pace from my black on black on black winter uniform!

    Posted 12.19.22 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      Hi Katie!! So it is actually the correct link… the pastel colorway is just sold out! It’s “A Colorful” in case you want to keep checking on it! xo, C

      Posted 12.19.22 Reply
      • Katie Gauthier wrote:

        Thank you for the reply- I will keep looking! Merry merry to you and yours!

        Posted 12.20.22 Reply