Fall Style | Thanksgiving Outfits

Hey friends…happy almost-weekend! Yesterday I shared our Thanksgiving ‘Rustic Glam’ table, along with the scrumptious Starbucks Pumpkin Loaf recipe! Let’s keep that Thanksgiving train going, shall we?!

Today I’ve got two darling Fall styles, perfect for your Thanksgiving day outfit! Obviously the heart of the holiday is all about gratitude, but it’s centered around food and football. Which means comfort is key…and what’s better for carb-loading than leggings?

Chunky Cardigan | Tunic Tee | Leggings | Plaid Scarf | Similar Boots | Hoop Earrings

The equivalence of wearing pajamas, but more acceptable in public…leggings are my go-to when I want to be comfy, but still pulled together. Plus, the stretchy waist is perfect for a double serving of sweet potatoes!

I found this entire look at JCPenney, so it’s as affordable as it is cute! The cardigan is a soft, chunky knit and the tunic a silky lightweight material…both long enough for leggings! #coveryourladybitsladies

And how about this scarf!? I love the classic plaid and gauzy lightweight fabric (perfect for wearing indoors!)…and it comes in five prints and up to 60% off!

Fit Tip: Everything is true to size, I’m wearing an XS

You could do a taupe or cognac boot, as well, but I like the solid black for a slimming effect. #passthepie

Chunky Cardigan | Tunic Tee | Leggings | Plaid Scarf | Similar Boots | Hoop Earrings

If leggings aren’t your jam…this combo is equally cute and laidback, and perfect for Fall!

Plaid Puffer Vest | Similar Striped Shirt | Similar Jeans | Similar Booties | Aviators

Have you seen a cuter puffer vest? I’m crazy for the plaid and brass buttons…definitely the chicest puffer I own! I paired it with a collared shirt to dress it up a tad, and the pattern play makes it more fun. The hood is removable, too.

Fit Tip: It’s true to size, I’m wearing XS.

Plaid Puffer Vest | Similar Striped Shirt | Similar Jeans | Similar Booties | Aviators

You know I have to zhush my sleeves and collar…read my tips for adding personality to your outfits here.

Plaid Puffer Vest | Similar Striped Shirt | Similar Jeans | Similar Booties | Aviators

So which outfit is more your style for Thanksgiving? What’s your weakness at the Thanksgiving feast? I’m all about the sides and dessert! And don’t miss the big Pre-Black Friday sale already happening at JCPenney! Amazing deals like Instant Pots under $50 and my favorite bamboo shades 50% off!

See you back here tomorrow for a sneak-peek of my Gibson x Glam ‘Cassie’ top!!! This amazing holiday collection is launching Monday!!

[Shop My Thanksgiving Styles]


*Photos by the darling and talented Mary Hafner. This post is created in collaboration with JCPenney, but all outfits, styling and food anticipation are my own. Thank you for supporting Hi Sugarplum sponsors.*



Leave a Comment


  1. Christina wrote:

    All so cute! That puffer vest is perfect!! I’m enjoying the thanksgiving content! I looove Christmas but don’t like skipping Thanksgiving.

    Posted 11.8.18 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      Poor Thanksgiving always gets the shaft! 😉

      Posted 11.8.18 Reply
  2. Sheaffer wrote:

    DARLING! Both outfits are absolutely DARLING!

    Posted 11.8.18 Reply
  3. Gail Wilson wrote:

    I saw the scarf and said out loud (at work!), ‘Is that a Burberry?!’ No way I could buy that AND stay married! It’s now in my basket along with vest – I don’t want the scarf to get lonely!

    I’m a Nordy’s girl first and foremost, but will make an exception for that darling scarf, tunic & vest. JCPenney is really stepping up their game!

    Posted 11.8.18 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      I thought the same thing! and then when it arrived and looked even better in person, I gave JCP a virtual fist bump! 😉

      Posted 11.8.18 Reply
  4. Hannah wrote:

    I randomly came across your blog after searching for some cognac booties, as the plaid puffer vest outfit kept popping up in my search! (Thank you for the inspiration by the way. I would have never thought to pair that plaid pattern with stripes.) I have to ask, are these the Dover Chelsea boots by Steve Madden in the color cognac? Also, do you have these boots in different colors? I wasn’t sure if they were the same boots, but in different colors in your other posts as these boots are sold out everywhere and I have no way of knowing if the brand offers it in multiple colors. Thanks for your style tips and great fashion finds!

    Posted 6.20.20 Reply