A New Mirror at the Waffle House

Thanks for appeasing my neurosis yesterday! Good to know you guys appreciate an organized space as much as I do!

Remember back when I was ‘Iced In’ (oh how I love Texas and our fear of a snow dusting!) and fell down the rabbit hole of online shopping? I posted this Horchow inspired Knot Mirror on sale at Kirkland’s for $80.

I should have known I wouldn’t forget about it easily. Then my friend enabled me further by handing over a Kirkland’s $15 off coupon! So I thought I’d run by on my lunch break and just check it out. No harm, no foul, right?

Well, what happened wuz…I got there and the mirror was an additional 25% off (or it was at their store across town, but after threatening mentioning that I’d drive to the store offering the additional discounts, they decided to honor it as well.)! So that meant the mirror would be $60, right? NOPE! They honored the $15 off coupon as well! (It never hurts to ask, people! That is my motto, much to my family’s horror when it’s not benefiting them.)

So here I stand at the store, staring at this heavy, solid wood mirror, thinking, “How can I not take this $600 look-a-like mirror home for $45?!?!”  You’re right, I had to. It was the right thing to do. So I hauled the 40″ wide beast-of-burden home and propped it up on the mantel (without bothering to remove the Winter Mantel decor).

100_2829

It was jarring, and intimidating….but it was such a steal…I had to like it!!?? I figured Mr. Sugarplum would poo-poo it anyway and put my waffling to rest (he’s unaware of the constant waffling that goes on inside my head). But to my surprise, he liked it. Or he just didn’t want to go down the path of mirror options I was sure to lead him on. So while I’m still waffling, I walk in on this scene a few days later:

(Pictures like this are why my family runs when they see me with a camera now. Impressive lunge, hon.)

Yep, my man drilling the crater necessary to hang the giant (did I mention it’s big and heavy?). So that pretty much put my waffling to rest. If the man goes after a project in his pajamas on a Saturday, we aren’t going back.

100_2995

And I have to say, I’m liking it more every day! Even though I think it’s hung a bit too high (but don’t have the heart to tell him!)

Picnik collage

Do you think it requires me to minimize the decor in the room? I’ve slimmed down the mantel and removed some pictures, but minimizing goes against my nature, so I’m not sure how long it will last. I do love to decorate the mantel (like here, here and here!)

Picnik collage

And we’re sold on painting the brick too. I think that will make a huge difference in bringing more cohesion to the room. Speaking of beasts, the armoire has been a thorn in my side for too long (but it’s amazing storage!!), hence the paint swatches taped up!

Picnik collage
What do you think? Is the Knot Mirror the perfect modern and graphic punch this traditional room needed? If not, I’ll Rita Return that thing yesterday!

Update: See the final mantel and mirror here!

Leave a Comment

54 Comments

  1. ok here are my thoughts… i love the mirror, i love it on the mantel, and i like it with the twiggy branches and a little more accessorized so it doesn't look stark. BUT something about the mirror with the textiles in the room isn't working for me. i don't think i like it with the soft greens. and this is totally my opinion- so feel free to disagree! i justw anted ro be 100% honest!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  2. AGohl wrote:

    I like the accessorized look better I think…

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  3. I really like it! Its quite a statement and i like it with the more minimal look.

    I definitely think it will look good with the fireplace painted and it might be worth bringing in a few more graphic items – I think changing the rug – (possibly bringing in the black and white one from the entrance hall might make a big difference)

    Have a lovely day!

    Rachie xo

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  4. love the mirror and SO impressed with his lunging abilities. I especially liked the tucked pajamas in the sock look!

    Paint the brick and the armoire and I think you will love it 🙂

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  5. I think it is fantastic! What a great deal! Not sure I'm loving it with the rug but.. that's just me. I like both items just not together! What color are you planning to paint the fireplace? I think it will look great!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  6. Anonymous wrote:

    Love the mirror, but in a different setting. I think your original assessment (too big and jarring) was spot on.

    It's like the old sesame street song, "Which of these things doesn't belong".

    Sorry to be a downer but it just isn't working for me in its current location. Love the mirror itself. You have a good eye. Perhaps in a different location in your house?

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  7. Heather wrote:

    Oh, I love the mirror. I think it makes the room! I like the accessorized look the best. I really like your idea of painting the bricks on the fireplace a lighter color; that would look great. As someone else commented, I am also impressed by your husband's lunging. 🙂

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  8. Anonymous wrote:

    He has a pant leg tucked for safety!

    I love the mirror itself…in the room…I'd paint it.

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  9. Niki wrote:

    Love it! I think it is a bit stark on the wall – maybe time for a new wall color? I also like more accessories as opposed to the minimal setting.

    Awesome steal!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  10. The mirror is fab!! And at 45 you can't really go wrong!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  11. hahahha that lunge has me laughing out loud. and the tucked in pajama pants. oh my, thank you for sharing that picture. ps. your mirror is so fab : )

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  12. I want that mirror SO badly- I've been lusting after it forever but when I went to the store, it was sold out- will check again. Yours looks amazing on your fireplace and I would definitely do the less accessorized version- the mirror makes such a statement and doesn't need other things diverting the eye away etc. I like it best with one of the crystal candelabras on either side. I would also definitely paint the brick and the armoir- the mirror is really graphic and I think it needs some stonger elements in the room to balance- does that make sense?

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  13. jandjhome wrote:

    Oh I love thisirror. It looks great in the space and the price…wow!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  14. Amazing deal! It looks awesome and it was so worth it!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  15. The mirror looks fab!!! I like it with the accessorized mantel, but without the gallery wall (and maybe with a different fabric on the chair?) I actually kind of like the texture the brick adds with the mirror, but it would look great painted, too. Great find, and I can't wait to see how the space ends up looking! (Oooh, now I'm reading the other comments and I'm thinking of the natural fireplace with a navy wall, or something like that. Okay, enough rambling!)

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  16. I'm with a few others who've already posted… The accessorized mantle looks fab with the mirror, but the gallery wall should go. And I LOVE the idea of painting the brick! What a steal on a lovely piece~ you go, girl!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  17. I like the height of the mirror! it's not too high, and not too low! Perfect! Looks great too!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  18. coolkids wrote:

    great score!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  19. Great score! I love how it looks and like it accessorized but without the gallery art wall. I actually like your fireplace as is. My thought might be switching out the rug to something solid or a simple graphic like a chevron or stripe which might work better with the mirror (the current one is pretty but maybe a bit too cute to go with the chic-ness of the mirror).
    Kudos to your man for sporting his plaid so well. 🙂

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  20. I was just thinking about you and this mirror yesterday! That is so funny. I was wondering if you had bought it. It's such a great mirror. Are you going to paint the armoire dark like the mirror?

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  21. I don't know what I love more, the bargain or the mirror itself…either way, it's a win-win situation! Cheers!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  22. Natalie wrote:

    I can't believe you got that for $45. If I lived in the same city, I would totally come steal it. I like the modern twist it adds ro your room. You have to keep it, its too fabulous (and cheap) to return!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  23. Love the mirror but not crazy about the rug now. I think painting out the armoire may help with it as well. The mirror definitely has a more modern/edgy feel than the rest of the room. My arm chair diagnosis would be
    1) switch out the rug
    2) paint the armoire a grey or soft green
    3) ditch the rug for something more neutral

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  24. Oh how I've missed you! Playing catch-up. That mirror is perfection in your room. And that photo of your husband is fabulous too 🙂 It is a great lunge haha.

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  25. nanazy wrote:

    I love the mirror and the fireplace as is, but what jumped out at me was the rug. I was replace it with someone more neutral.

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  26. Simply LKJ wrote:

    Cassie, love the mirror. I know you are thinking of painting the brick, but if you are looking to go white or light, I think the mantle will get lost and the mirror will stand out even more. I'd paint the mantle black, it would help anchor the mirror. I'd also paint the armoire a dark color. If you were to change out the rug, I'd go neutral,so you can change things around whenever you feel like it without it competing with your accessories. I like the mantle with the accessories, but prefer no gallery wall below the pass through. My two cents!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  27. DO NOT return that mirror!!! It is fabulous! Can't stop giggling at the lunge photo!!! My husband would kill me if I posted that!!!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  28. Hi there, I'm your newest follower. Love all your decorations and crafts. Cheers

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  29. l.o.v.e. the mirror, great find! i think i like the minimal mantel better. but i do think that if you paint the brick and the armoire (and maybe get a less graphic rug?), the mantel/mirror could handle more accessories.

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  30. I am so obsessed with that mirror!!! i just looked online and they dont have it anymore!!! AHHH! and i dont think i have a kirklands anywhere nearby…so i guess Im saying I super jealous! LOVE IT! and love the pic of your hubby hanging it!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  31. I really like the mirror but I think it would look better in my house so maybe you could just send it 🙂 I also don't think it's too high – you can handle height because of the high ceilings… draw your eye up and all of that mumbo jumbo?

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  32. Anonymous wrote:

    Okay, Cassie, here is my opinion, which is worth what you pay for it, as are all of the others:
    I think the mirror looks great. The charm of a room is due to the mix of things – new, old, sentimental, dark and somber, whimsical and light etc and especially things whose only reason for being there is that YOU LOVE THEM. Please back away from the sameness that will lead you down the road to chevron rugs, chevron painted furniture, trellis-y fabrics and all the other "unique" things that you'll currently encounter on literally thousands of blogs…torn up paperbacks wrapped in string???!! Words (Faith, Dream. Eat, Love,! etc etc) on walls??! Really? To scroll through a lot of blogs, you'd think everyone had joined a decorating cult! Don't drink the kool-aid and join in these trends that will, down the road, label your house as early 2000's as surely as bargello in the '80's and toile in the '90's….trust your taste. Trust your eye. Ali

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  33. First off, people are hilarious, I just love reading other peeps' comments…second, that mirror is absolutely fabulous! I'm still laughing at the pic you posted of Mr. Sugarplum…pretty sure I would have the kabosh put on *all* blogging if I posted a pic like that, he is such a good sport!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  34. Talk about getting crackhead prices you definitely made out pretty good. Maybe I should stop by Kirklands more often I tend to stay away because their decor is mo' on the traditional side. I like minimal better.

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  35. ChRiS wrote:

    nice mirror u got lucky with the price….but looks very modern in that room.

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  36. So funny I just used this Kirkland's mirror above my mantel in the DC Magazine shoot which I will share on the blog later this week. It's a fantastic mirror for an amazing price!! I like it hung higher and I like it softened with fun branches on your mantel, forget minimalism!! Bring in you next to it.
    I'm going to use mine in my new office but while we were waiting for the mirror I ordered it worked perfect. KEEP IT!!!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  37. The Zhush wrote:

    Everything, down to the last word that Danielle O said is my comment too! oh, and its not too high…its PERFECT!:) (literally!)

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  38. A girl can never have too many accessories! I say go for the extras and skip the minimal look. Great find and great post! 🙂

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  39. Anonymous wrote:

    After getting a close gander at your handyman's pajamas, I'm not surprised how your room turned out. Cleopatra's Gruncle

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  40. Michaela wrote:

    That picture is so funny. I'm in a tea shop studying for finals, well..taking a break now…and I started laughing out loud! My parents and friends run from cameras now, too. Love the mirror…and I actually think it's at a great height!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  41. You HAD to buy it! It would have been a crime not to at that great price! I think it looks great!

    Posted 3.15.11 Reply
  42. What a great deal! You can't pass up on amazing items like that, especially as a world renown blogger. It would be absurd.

    Mr. Goodwill Hunting

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  43. I totally bookmarked this mirror when you originally posted it! Just love it and think it looks stunning on your mantel! I actually like more accessories…I think it balances it out! 🙂

    PS…I would love for you to enter my giveaway: http://schuelove.blogspot.com/2011/03/my-first-giveaway-emily-inspired.html

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  44. kathie wrote:

    ahhh, okay, i'll leave my two cents!
    keep the mirror. but to balance better, paint your mantel black and leave the brick as is. paint the armoire a dark color, as well. change the carpet out – too cutesy for this "statement mirror". painting the walls a bit deeper color would help. it will be interesting to see what you decide. do remember, however, it's just opinions; do what you love.

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  45. emily wrote:

    That mirror is awesome! I think it looks amazing there! I like it with some accessories — I don't think you have to scale back much, if at all.

    And seriously, what a sweet hubby to hang the mirror without even asking! Love the pants leg tucked into the sock!

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  46. Andrea wrote:

    Love the mirror. Was your sweet husband posing for that picture or did you catch him by surprise? ha ha.

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  47. Woowho! Love this mirror and so glad you found it at a great price! I think it looks fantastic accessorized. It's big and bold enough to stand up to the accents.

    Your room is so light and airy that I think the black weights it down a bit. Here's a totally whack-a-doo idea…what about a paint job? Say light blue and white? It would be so crisp and clean and look fantastic with your sofa and run!

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  48. TamStyles wrote:

    i am going to kirklands..i never go there and they just opened one.

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  49. I love that mirror and actually think it looks like the perfect height! I also love that shot of your hubs with his pj's tucked into his sock! haha, love it!

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  50. C wrote:

    Actually have that mirror, but the brown version (not quite as striking, so I painted it grey). Love the black version you scored! So I like your mix of styles in the room, but the rug + mirror just isn't doing it for me. I don't mind blending styles, but it's all a bit schizophrenic now with the addition of the mirror. Like I said, I dig the mirror and a new rug (+ another armoire makeover might be good). Just my opinion– love the blog!

    Posted 3.16.11 Reply
  51. Oh how I love that mirror- do not return! Nice arse Mr. Sugarplum! ha!

    Posted 3.17.11 Reply
  52. Erin wrote:

    Love the mirror! The photo of your hubs hanging the mirror had me cracking up! That totally could have been my husband. I had to show him so he knew there were other husbands asked to hang heavy mirrors first thing on a weekend morning, pj's and all and has a wife that has to take pictures of the process. He's not alone.

    Posted 3.17.11 Reply
  53. Love the mirror, what a steal, and I think less is more. Love the idea of painting the brick, these two elements don't compliment each other that well right now.

    But best, the picture of your husband, oh my goodness, that is too funny. pj's and all…my family runs as well.

    Janell

    Posted 3.17.11 Reply
  54. Jewel wrote:

    Love that mirror, and I like the whole way you've styled the room altogether. It just fits together so well.

    Posted 3.30.11 Reply