Amazon Fashion Finds | September

Happy Friday, friends, and cheers to the weekend! We had plans to head to the lake, but after this insanely hot and dry summer, the water levels are too low to do much of anything!

I’m headed back to the doctor this morning to have my ankle x-rayed… and crossing all my fingers and toes she’ll let me transition to a walking boot, but it’s not likely. It’s been a little over a month since I broke it, so hopefully at the very least, I’m half-way there?!

I can hardly believe another month has passed, but today it’s time for your favorite series, my Amazon Fashion Finds! I started these Fashion Finds over 7 years ago, and they quickly became reader faves. It takes some intense digging to find the good stuff, but I love the challenge of discovering such gems!

Mama Sugarplum was sweet enough to join me again!

Sizing info: I’m 5’4″ 125-ish pounds, and usually wear an XS and 26 jeans, and Mom is 5’2″ and wears the same size. My fit tips and sizing recommendations are included with each description.

Dresses //

If you’re more on the hunt for fall styles, I noticed this favorite dress is finally back-in-stock, and available in new colors! I wear it in warmer months with sandals and slides, and transition it to booties when it starts to cool. It’s cute for concerts, too.

Fit Tip: We’re both wearing a size Small dress, but I wouldn’t size up.

Spotty Drop Waist Dress (Leopard Light Green) | Chain Slide Mules

Spotty Drop Waist Dress (Leopard Light Green & Leopard Coffee)
Bracelet Set | Saddle Bag | Removable Strap (Color: Stripe Rose Brown)

I love a good ‘house dress’, and this one is not only soft and flowy, but comes in the cutest colors and prints! It has a full, batwing sleeve, and gathers under the chest. Add a belt and jean jacket for a little more shape.

Fit Tip: We’re both wearing size Small, but I wouldn’t size up.

Print Maxi Dress (A Purple & A Green 001)
on Mama SP: Leather Slide Sandals | Belt // on me: Golden Goose Sneakers | Bracelet Set

This satin dress is so lovely, the photos don’t really do it justice! The pleats are beautifully placed, with a ruffled neckline and full balloon sleeves. The shape is forgiving, and it’s easily dressy enough for events.

Fit Tip: Mama SP is wearing a size Small dress.

Ruffle Neck Crinkle Dress (Rose Red & Lake Blue) | Nude Pumps (Similar HERE)

Sets //

This summer was all about shorts sets, and now I’m taking my obsession to fall… thankfully Amazon has an abundance of amazing styles for less! This is a super-soft knit in a medium weight, and is darling with sneakers, mules, or even loafers. It comes in a ton of colors, and is comfy as it is chic. (You’ll never believe where Mom and I found these amazing look-for-less loafers!)

Fit Tip: We are wearing a size Small set.

Split Hem Long Sleeve Set (Y Light Blue)
on Mama SP: Loafers // on me: Golden Goose Sneakers | Saddle Bag | Removable Strap (Color: Stripe Rose Brown)

You’ve seen this set a few times… it’s been a favorite of mine for awhile! Mom couldn’t wait to try it on for herself, and promptly ordered her own. It’s a waffle weave, with a pull-on elastic waist and longer tunic-style top. It comes in tons of colors, but warning… it’s addicting!

Fit Tip: Mama SP is wearing a size Small set.

Henley Long Sleeve Set (color: Apricot) | Loafers

This shorts set is an incredible look-for-less! It feels almost exactly like the popular Varley set, with a silky-soft jersey material. I love the oversized collar, and side detail on the shorts.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small set.

Wide Collar Half-Zip Set (Khaki) | Bracelet Set

This set has gone viral, and with good reason! It’s identical to the pricey Free People set, and the quality is so good! The pants have a fun ‘hammer style’ that are somehow super comfy and flattering! I love the drop-shoulder sweater, and have also paired it with this skirt.

Fit Tip: Mama SP is wearing a size Small set.

Designer-Inspired Long Set (White) | Golden Goose Sneakers

Sweaters //

A great closet staple, this cotton sweater is perfect for multi-seasons, with an easy shape and flattering mock neck. The quality is so impressive for the price, and it comes in a range of colors.

Fit Tip: We are both wearing a size Small sweater, a size up for a relaxed fit.

Mock Neck Sweater (Black & Purple)
Cropped Flare Jeans (size 2) (code CASSIE15) | Golden Goose Sneakers

Stop scrolling and add this cardigan to your cart!! It’s crazy soft and stretchy, in the perfect medium weight for wearing alone or layering… and you won’t believe the price and color options! I seriously want it in half the colors!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small cardigan and Small-Short pants.

Button Cardigan (Fc280_khaki)
Wide Leg Pants | Chain Slide Mules | Heart Toggle Necklace (code SUGARPLUM10) (Similar HERE)

You know I love to add a jean jacket, but this cardigan is another great layer for transitional style! Just toss it on over your favorite summer sundresses or maxi skirts, and you can wear them for another month or more!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size XS dress and Small cardigan.

Button Cardigan (Fc280_khaki)
Tiered Maxi Dress (XS) | Black Slide Sandals | Woven Leather Tote Bag | Bracelet Set | Heart Toggle Necklace (code SUGARPLUM10) (Similar HERE)

Preppy ‘lady jackets’ and cardigans are everywhere this season… but they tend to start at $120 and up! Here is a darling option that comes in a bunch of colors and stripes. It has a boxy shape, front pockets, and even brass buttons for extra styles.

Fit Tip: We’re both wearing a size Small cardigan, but it’s oversized so definitely don’t size up.

Striped Cardigan (Apricot & Black White)
on Mama SP: Straight Leg Jeans | Loafers // on me: Crewneck Tee | Cropped Flare Jeans (size 2) (code CASSIE15) | Medium Hoop Earrings

How about J.Crew style and quality, but with Amazon prices?! That’s definitely what you’ll get with this puffed sleeve sweater! It’s super soft and stretchy, in a medium weight… so cute with jeans, or dressed up with trousers and skirts.

Fit Tip: We’re both wearing a size Small sweater.

Puff Sleeve Sweater Tee (A-bright Pink & A-beige)
on Mama SP: Straight Leg Jeans | Loafers // on me: Cropped Flare Jeans (size 2) (code CASSIE15) | Golden Goose Sneakers | Bracelet Set

Another ‘lady jacket’ style… this one is a heavier weight, sort of a cross between a sweater and a jacket, in tweed-like material. I’m crazy for the buttons and gold thread detail, plus the cropped shape makes it perfect for pairing with dresses or high-waisted trousers.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small cardigan.

Pearl Cardigan (Red-pink) | Cropped Flare Jeans (size 2) (code CASSIE15)

Skirts & Pants //

My photos and lack of styling aren’t doing these skirts any favors, but I was extremely impressed with both these midi skirts…. especially the satin one! In fact I love it so much, it was the first time since breaking my ankle that I truly missed clothes! Style them with graphic tees, tanks, and jean jackets, slouchy sweaters, or a cami and blazer… they’re super versatile, comfy, and so chic!

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small in both skirts.

Abstract Maxi Skirt (Black White) | Midi Slip Skirt (Black)
Left: Mock Neck Sweater | Black Slide Sandals | Bracelet Set // Right: Hoodie | Golden Goose Sneakers

These pants are a no-brainer! I now have them in multiple colors, and love them with everything from tanks to blouses to sweaters. They’re a soft, woven material, fully lined and with an elastic waist in the back for a comfy fit. See how I’ve worn them HERE, HERE, and HERE.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small-Short pant.

Wide Leg Pants (Ivory White & Camel)
Left: Button Cardigan (Fc280_khaki) | Chain Slide Mules | Heart Toggle Necklace (code SUGARPLUM10) (Similar HERE) // Right: Button Cardigan (Fsw007_black) | Cap Toe Ballet Flats

Jackets //

I couldn’t hit ‘add to cart‘ fast enough with this sherpa… I’m definitely having a moment with green this season (I even painted my son’s room green, see that HERE). This sherpa jacket is super soft and cozy, with great quality and fun color-block style.

Fit Tip: I’m wearing a size Small jacket.

Fuzzy Zip-Up Jacket (Sage Green/Dark Green, Color Block)
Crewneck Tee | Cropped Flare Jeans (size 2) (code CASSIE15) | Medium Hoop Earrings

This quilted jacket is as soft as it is cute! It has a brushed finish and similar style to the popular Free People jacket, but for less than half the price. A medium weight, it’s a great transitional jacket to pair with jeans and athletic wear.

Fit Tip: It’s oversized, I’m wearing a size XS jacket.

Quilted Snap Jacket (Bubble Gum)
Crewneck Tee | Cropped Flare Jeans (size 2) (code CASSIE15)

Athletic Wear //

Our favorite sweat suits are back… this time with a flattering, easy-to-wear wide leg!! Made of super soft cotton with fleece lining, they are incredible quality. Mix and match the styles and colors, we’re partial to the hoodie and crewneck.

Fit Tip: We’re wearing a size Small in all the pieces, which is a touch big, but will shrink some in the dryer.

on Mama SP: Crewneck | Sweatpants | Golden Goose Sneakers
on me: Hoodie (Light Grey Heather) | Sweatpants (Light Grey Heather) | ON Cloud Sneakers (TTS)

Fit Tip: Mama SP is wearing size Small in every piece.

Left: Hoodie (Light Grey Heather) | Sweatpants (Light Grey Heather) | Golden Goose Sneakers // Right: Crewneck | Sweatpants

I pretty much live in these quarter-zip pullovers once Fall and Winter hit… they are so stinking cute, and the quality is on par with higher-end brands. These leggings are by far my faves from Amazon!! They have just enough compression to help you feel held-in, without being uncomfortable, and come in the softest airbrush finish.

Fit Tip: She’s wearing a size Small pullover and XS leggings.

Pop Collar Half-Zip Pullover (Pink) | Leggings | Similar NB Sneakers

The same quality sweatshirt as the black one above, but sized up for a longer, more relaxed fit, perfect for pairing with leggings. And the leggings really are that good! I have them in three colors, and something tells me I’ll be adding more this season!

Fit Tip: Mom’s wearing a size Medium pullover and XS leggings.

Crewneck (Eggshell White) | Leggings | Similar NB Sneakers

So many fun finds this month, right? I honestly love everything we shared!! As for your recent faves, these are your top five Amazon Fashion Finds lately…

Tiered Mini Skirt (Caramel, Small)
Racerback Tank (Small) | Jean Jacket | Saddle Bag | Removable Strap (Stripe Rose Brown) | Cut-Out Sandals | Layered Initial Necklace | Gold Bead Bracelets | Medium Hoop Earrings

Half-Zip Pullover (Style2-white, Small) | Similar Jeans | Similar Loafers

Racerback Tank (XS) | Maxi Skirt (Small) | Woven Leather Tote Bag | Straw Hat (code SUGARPLUM10) | Sunglasses | Medium Hoop Earrings | Bracelets

Cardigan Sweater (Black, XS) | Similar Jeans | Buckle Mules (TTS) | Beaded Headband

Tie Waist Chiffon Dress (Flower Black, Small) | Tie Waist Flowy Dress (Red, Small)
LeftStrappy Heels (size up half) | Gold Bead Bracelets // RightBlock Heel Booties (Nude, TTS)

Stay tuned this weekend, I’ll be sharing a full video try-on session in my Instagram Stories HERE. And find more fall inspiration in my recent Dressing Room Diaries HERE, and 30 Fall Transitional Styles HERE. Happy weekend, lovebugs!

PS – Find my Sugarplum Amazon Shop HERE, with my top picks in a range of categories. I also have a ‘Sugar Shack’ list in my Amazon Store for all lake house links! And if you’re looking for some of my fave random finds, all my Monday Mail Day discoveries are HERE. And for those asking, the fun artwork behind me is HERE.


adidas // Up to 60% off select shoes and clothing

Avara // Shop Sale HERE, plus 15% off with code CASSIE15

Colleen Rothschild // 26% site-wide with code CELEBRATE

Gap // Extra 30% off your purchase with code GREAT

Gibsonlook // Shop Sale HERE, plus 10% off with code SUGARPLUM10

J.Crew // Up to 50% off outwear and Fall essentials

J.Crew Factory // Extra 25% off orders $125+ with code MORE4FALL

Kendra Scott // Shop Sale HERE, plus free shipping on orders $85+

LOFT // Up to 40% off your purchase

Nordstrom // Shop women’s markdowns HERE

Old Navy // 30% off your purchase

Social Threads // Save 25% on select Fall favorites with code FALL25

tarte // 15% off eligible items with code CASSIE15

Leave a Comment


  1. Sandy wrote:

    So great to see Mama SP in these looks. Helpful too.
    Your injury was one of the worst sounding accidents I have ever heard!
    Don’t rush the healing, you will love the Phys. Therapy (warm water? Hot tub?) : )
    And take your vitamins (C!) for healing! : )

    Posted 9.22.23 Reply
    • Cassie wrote:

      Thank you, Sandy!!! I am doing my best to see the silver lining(s) and enjoy this downtime <3 <3 <3 Xo, c

      Posted 9.25.23 Reply