When I shared Part 1 of your Sugarplum favorites (see them HERE), I knew you had great taste… but y’all really showed up. The response was so fun to see — and clearly we needed a Part 2!
These are the rest of the reader-loved, tried-and-true, reordered-on-repeat favorites that you’ve shopped, shared, and messaged me about over and over. Some are longtime staples, some were surprise hits, but every single one earned its place because you loved it.
There’s something so special about this list because it’s not just what I love — it’s what we love. The pieces that worked. The finds that delivered. The ones you told your friends about.
Your Sugarplum Favorite Finds //
Stackable Ring | Gold Ring | Silver Tennis Bracelet | Love Bracelet | Gold Geo Bracelet | Gold Tennis Bracelet | Diamond Statement Ring | Diamond Band | Gold Love Ring | Gold Earrings | Heart Charms Necklace | Gold Puffy Heart Pendant Necklace | Heart Link Necklace | Shop All HERE
PJ Set (Small) | Shop All HERE
Packing Cubes | Shop All HERE
Lint Roller | Shop All HERE
Retinol Supreme Night Oil | Vitamin C Brightening Serum | Glycolic Acid Peel Pads | Intense Hydrating Mask | Sheer Renewal Cream | Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream | Shop All HERE
Cashmere Sweater (Small) | Shop All HERE
Sweatpants (Small) | Shop All HERE
Set (Small) | Sweater (Small) | Hat | Purse | Luggage | Duffle Bag | Shoes | Shop All HERE
Maxi Dress (XXS) | Bag | Sandals | Shop All HERE
Sports Bra (Small) | Leggings (XS) | Tennis Shoes | Crewneck Sweater (Small) | Silk Pants (Small) | Turtleneck (Small) | Sneakers | Wide Leg Jeans (26×30) | Flats | Jacket (XS) | T-Shirt (XS) | Palazzo Jeans (26×30) | Heels | Shop All HERE
Sandals | Raffia Purse | Shell Purse | Gingham Top (Small) | Jacket (Small) | Jeans (26×30) | Pore Pads | Shop All HERE
Wrap Skort (XS) | Tank (Small) | Sunglasses | Turtleneck (Small) | Jeans (26×30) | Flats | Dress (Small) | Raffia Purse | Sandals | Sports Bra (Small) | Leggings (Small) | Tennis Shoes | Shop All HERE
I always say the best recommendations are the ones that stand the test of time — and these clearly have. Thank you for trusting me with your closets, your beauty counters, your homes and your travel plans! It truly means more than you know.
If you’re new here, this list is a pretty good snapshot of the Sugarplum community favorites. And if you’ve been around a while… I have a feeling you already own at least one of these. 😉
If you’re looking for even more Sugarplum Favorite Finds, check out Part 1 HERE!
