Polka Dot Cake

Hiya, friends! My penthouse days are over, and I’m back at work nursing a big old cup of coffee this morning. But it’s worth it for such a great weekend spent with friends. I got to meet and spend time with new and old blog pals (like Natalie, Caycee, Megan, Carly, Chassity & Jamie)…I plan on sharing more about the weekend soon…but I’m working on a surprise to go with it! I can’t wait to share it with you…let’s just say there are 25 reasons you’ll want to ‘swagger’ back for it.

But this morning I’m wishing I had a piece of this cake to go with my coffee…nothing better than cold cake in the morning! Somehow over the years, the cake has become the centerpiece of our birthday parties. No matter how much I outsource, or how simple the celebration, the cake is one place I pour my heart and attention.

I pick up store-bought cupcakes and cookies for many events…but when it comes to my kids, and their birthdays…I’ve made their cake every single year. For some reason, that’s a memory I want them to have and cherish. Maybe I hope it will compensate for all the times I’m not putting in a stellar mom performance.

Since this was our third Art Party in as many years, we’d kind of worn the rainbow theme out (see them here, here and here). I still like the idea of using bright colors, but this time we used them in the form of polka dots.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

{What You Need}
2 Boxes White Cake Mix (why not let Betty do what Betty does best)
Ingredients listed on the box
Food Color (I prefer these gel colors for more vibrant shades)
Cake Ball pan or maker (I used this one, except mine also makes donuts & cupcakes)
White Frosting
Round Cake Pan (I used this 6-inch for a taller cake)
Mix one cake according to the instructions on the box. To really make your polka dots pop, you want your cake pure white…so don’t use egg yolks.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Separate the batter into smaller bowls, and dye to your preferred colors.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Bake 18-24 cake balls…which uses about half the cake batter.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

You might want to bake extras, because they disappear fast.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Whip up the other box of batter, and pour about half an inch in the bottom of your cake pan, then place the cake balls on top.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Pour just enough batter to cover them, then bake according to instructions on the box.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

I only have one 6-inch pan, so I was impatient and removed them too soon…but nothing a generous helping of frosting can’t disguise.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Keeping with the polka dot theme, I decorated it with round candy melts in colors that coordinated with the party.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Art Party

The downside to cakes with surprises in the middle, is you don’t know of it’s success or failure until you’re cutting into it!

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

Each slice wielded different color and size polka dots, but that added to the fun.

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Art Party

I intended to take more pictures of the different slices, but it was gone before I had the chance. Guess it tasted as yummy as it was cute!

Hi Sugarplum | Polka Dot Cake

I thought the cake balls would be tough or dry since they’d been baked twice, but they had the same consistency as the rest of the cake. There are so many variances of this cake…you can change the colors of the polka dots to fit any party scheme…and I’d love to make a chocolate cake with white cake dots! Happy Monday, love bugs…hope your day includes cold cake and coffee!

Leave a Comment

17 Comments

  1. Ellen from Ask Away wrote:

    OMG that is SO COOL!! so talented ! I could never do that lol but wow that came out perfect!

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  2. Katie {Little House of Four} wrote:

    Beautiful cake! Perfect for a little girls birthday!

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  3. caycee wrote:

    You are such a rockstar!! And so I knew I was going to love you, but now I am officially in love with you!! You seriously are the sweetest and the coolest ever!

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  4. Jennifer @ Dimples and Tangles wrote:

    So fun and I'm glad your girlie loved it! I always insist on making my kids' birthday cakes, too, even though I really want to just place an order at Sam's lots of times! It's so fun to look back at all of the cakes of birthdays past. We did a similar polka dot cake last year for my daughter's 10th birthday…still one of my favorites ever!

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  5. Mable Burt wrote:

    Oh so cute, my daughter's birthday is coming up and I know she would love this cake.. Thanx for the idea

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  6. Sarah Tucker wrote:

    I might attempt to make this for my kiddos before the end of the year is up. They would LOVE it!

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  7. Because Shanna Said So wrote:

    This is too much fun…my girls would die over this cake!! It was so great meeting you this weekend! Your blog is adorable!! Gah!! I am addicted!! 🙂

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  8. Jillian Manesh wrote:

    this cake is So much fun!! love it!! xo jillian – cornflake dreams

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  9. Heather{Our Life In a Click} wrote:

    Oh my gosh! Must try this. I thought it was going to be too tricky for me but cake balls in the batter, I can do that!! Yay!!

    Posted 4.28.14 Reply
  10. Sheaffer {Pinterest Told Me To} wrote:

    Okay………so two things………1) YOUR NEW DESIGN IS AMAZING! I love it so SO much! 2) You are a cake baking genius. Girl, you can bake me a cake anytime.
    🙂

    Posted 4.29.14 Reply
  11. Mix and Match Mama wrote:

    Oh my goodness! The details that went into this cake just blow my mind. Seriously…it's fabulous!

    Posted 4.29.14 Reply
  12. Georgiana wrote:

    Wow, this is a wonderful idea. Must try it!

    Posted 4.29.14 Reply
  13. Keitha M wrote:

    Love that! I'm so on that for my twincesses party

    Posted 4.29.14 Reply
  14. Rhonda @ home.made. wrote:

    Love this cake and have plans to try this soon! I too, have always been determined to make my kids' cakes for their birthdays… until this year. I let my talented sister step in and make the cakes since things were too cuh-razy – I'm holding on to the teensiest bit of regret that I didn't do it myself but I figure auntie is the next best thing, right?

    Posted 4.30.14 Reply
  15. MomHomeGuide.com wrote:

    Beautiful! My twins are turning 11 in a month, so I will have to surprise them with this cake! Now, if you only had great birthday party ideas you could share! (We don't know what to do this year!)

    Posted 5.1.14 Reply
  16. Ashley@AttemptsAtDomestication wrote:

    LOVE this! It's seriously such a clever idea! Way to go!

    Posted 5.1.14 Reply
  17. adrienne wrote:

    I just made this and can't wait to cut into it!!!

    Posted 6.26.14 Reply